NewsHounds
We watch Fox so you don't have to!
  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Forum
  • Blogroll
  • Donate
  • Shop
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
Home →

Medical Experts Provide Reasons To Question Glenn Beck’s Neurological Disease Claims

Posted by Ellen -7859.80pc on November 13, 2014 · Flag

Beck.png

Glenn Beck’s tale of a neurological disease that makes him “look crazy” is looking like it’s just the kind of baloney we suspected.

A few days ago, I posted about Beck’s tearful, melodramatic monologue detailing his bizarre symptoms. He claimed that the eventual explanation was autoimmune disorder and adrenal fatigue. Since then, Raw Story did some investigating and what they found calls a lot of Beck’s story into question:

Raw Story’s first point is that Beck’s medical guru, “chiropractic neurologist” Dr. Ted Carrick has been dismissed as a quack by Yale University neurologist Dr. Steven Novella. As someone who has been involved in alternative medicine, I will not condemn Carrick or Beck just on this score. But this certainly fits in with the red flags about Beck’s credibility in the rest of what Raw Story wrote.

Besides Beck’s doctor, Raw Story raises a question about the diagnosis:

Raw Story spoke with a representative of Emory Health Care in Atlanta who pointed out that Beck’s symptoms do not actually match those typically associated with adrenaline fatigue, which is a syndrome that affects people exposed to high levels of stress over long periods of time.

…Many of Beck’s symptoms, however, are common to patients suffering from panic disorder.

Yale’s Dr. Novella is also skeptical of Beck’s narrative and called for him to disclose his medical records to back up his claims:

In a conversation with Raw Story, Novella said, “If you’re going to use your personal medical history as a public figure in order to make a point, then I think you’re obligated to make your medical record public.”

…“I care about this because I’m a physician,” Novella explained, “and he’s promoting a dubious diagnosis and a dubious practitioner and we have absolutely no way of knowing if anything he’s saying about his own medical history is accurate.”

In my post, I wrote that despite my suspicions about Beck’s tale, I’d take him at his word until there’s some evidence pointing elsewhere.

I’d call this evidence.

You can watch Beck’s videos below.

(H/T Aria)

Follow @NewsHounds

Follow @NewsHoundEllen


Do you like this post?
Tweet

Showing 13 reactions



    Review the site rules
mj - the same one commented 2014-11-14 18:15:02 -0500 · Flag
So — where’s Chuck Kenney to browbeat us over being “insensitive” to Beck’s illness?

“Sorry, but find this article incredibly insensitive. I am in the same boat after suffering a life-threatening seizure. Nothing to joke about here. Not classy!”

http://www.newshounds.us/glenn_beck_says_he_has_a_rare_neurological_disease_that_makes_him_look_crazy_11102014

.
Doug Dupuis commented 2014-11-14 07:02:50 -0500 · Flag
I think he came up with this to use as a defense in his upcoming defamation lawsuit brought against him. I can see his lawyer now saying to the judge, my client was not in right frame of mind when he said the defendant was involved with the Boston Marathon bombing.
Antoinette commented 2014-11-14 03:09:38 -0500 · Flag
Jane is correct. Actor Glenn Beck is in dire need of intensive, long-term psychiatric care. He is not well mentally. He’s not the only one screwed up.

Photo Op Hannocchio also needs intensive, life-time psychiatric care. He has a lot going on inside his dark soul. There’s another side of him that is troubling.

We have a dirty secret about these frauds. Many of them are so screwed up mentally they turn to drugs and alcohol to soothe their mental pain. It’s very common in the film and television industry. News folks are not immune.

NOTE TO MASSES

Beck isn’t the only one who is troubled.
Jane S commented 2014-11-14 00:53:44 -0500 · Flag
Well, I’ll certainly buy the “panic disorder” idea. The man is obviously terribly screwed up and intelligent enough, unlike say Hannity, to be aware somewhere in at least his subconscious that he’s doing wrong.

As for the hack docs he’s consulting— he’s hardly the last or the first to reach out frantically to people like that when traditional medicine doesn’t offer him anything to hang onto to explain his problems. The man needs intensive, long-term psychiatric are — not from Ablow, but somebody competent — to sort out his problems, but that’s an idea many totally screwed-up people can’t deal with.

I feel sorry for him, actually. Chronic cognitive dissonance is hard to live with.
Aria Prescott commented 2014-11-13 20:08:38 -0500 · Flag
As I commented before, when Beck inserts a medical condition into his story, and the person really has it, he goes into detail. I mean, he’ll milk them for microscopic detail, and read entire medical sites to you when he’s out of things to say about their account. Remember when he used his Cerebral palsied daughter as a prop? When he claimed he was going blind? When he had his viewers tell him how the ACA was gonna kill them?

Even if he didn’t know the name of the condition, he shot off more medical exposition than a House marathon.

Which brings me to one of Beck’s biggest and most obvious tells: The more he’s lying, the vaguer he gets, especially when it’s healthcare issues, or a miraculous recovery story. He was very general with this symptoms, and his medical pedagoging was almost non-existent. That was a huge red flag, even without the sketchy way he was acting.
mlp ! commented 2014-11-13 20:04:41 -0500 · Flag
I’m with Jan on this…..nobody can discern truth from fantasy better than Ablow. I think I’d like to hear his diagnosis before condemning anyone.
BWAAAAAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!
Fuck these people.
truman commented 2014-11-13 19:42:22 -0500 · Flag
Becktard is a proven grifter. Anyone believing anything he says should look into buying that bridge in Brooklyn.
Blue Turtle commented 2014-11-13 16:20:05 -0500 · Flag
It would be so intensely ironic if Beck is a victim of a chiropractic scam artist. The scammer getting scammed. But I’m sure Beck won’t question this diagnosis which conveniently seems to absolve him of any bad behavior past and present.
Joseph West commented 2014-11-13 15:58:46 -0500 · Flag
Jan, even though Ablow’s had no problem with diagnosing people, I don’t recall his attempting to diagnose actual medical conditions. He’s preferred to limit his “professional” diagnoses to mental issues (even though he has no business doing so without a face-to-face meeting).
Joseph West commented 2014-11-13 15:49:41 -0500 · Flag
Ellen, I’m with scooter on this. There was NEVER any reason to give Beck the benefit of the doubt. You only give that to people who have made errors in judgment but haven’t generally been mistaken on most issues. Beck has done nothing but been mistaken and he’s also engaged in some incredibly shady dealings in the past—such as hawking that gold service without informing people of how it benefited him in the process.
Jan Hall commented 2014-11-13 15:23:07 -0500 · Flag
I’m waiting for the Diagnosis from Dr. Allblow :^)
scooter commented 2014-11-13 15:12:42 -0500 · Flag
I called BS on this story when Beck first made his announcement. Please folks, the man is a grifter, nothing more. He is after sympathy and $$$ from rubes who will donate to help him. He is a liar, a fraud, and anyone who buys into his schtick deserves whatever they get. Screw you Glenn – you are the proverbial boy who cried wolf. Nobody with half a lick of common sense believes a thing you say.
NewsHounds posted about Medical Experts Provide Reasons To Question Glenn Beck’s Neurological Disease Claims on NewsHounds' Facebook page 2014-11-13 14:20:35 -0500
Yes, Beck should make his medical records public.








or sign in with Facebook or email.
Follow @NewsHounds on Twitter
Subscribe with RSS


We’ve updated our Privacy Policy
Sign in with Facebook, Twitter or email.
Created with NationBuilder